Archives
CHANNELS
 Current Affairs
 Engaged Circle
 De-Classified
 Edit -Opinion
 Society & Lifestyle
 Features
 Bouquets & Bricks
 Business & Economy
 Archives
People Power
Wanted: Your story

 
THE HUB
Those Who Make The Grade

 

JEAN DREZE
Rights Activist
Stoic, simplicity incarnate, in his perennial kurta, he can be deceptive. He has co-authored books with Amartya Sen, and Sen owes a lot to his sensibility to be where he is in the safe globalised zone of ‘reforms with a human face’. Not for Dreze. He can be doggedly dogged. If he was beaten up during the long march for ‘jobs to all’ recently, it has only made him more resolute. From being part of hunger strikes for the right to food campaign in Rajasthan, to the employment guarantee act, this economist has proved that a country is what you do for its people. Rest is theory.
 
HABIB TANVIR
Playwright Activist
He was only spoofing the Brahminical caste society with his play Ponga Pandit, but his play was stoned across the Hindi heartland by the Hindutva rabble during the bjp regime. He didn’t care; this man is relentless. From his first production, Mitti ki Gadi (a translation of Shudraka’s Mrichchakatikam) to Charandas Chor and Asghar Wajahat’s Jisne Lahore Nahin Dekhya, Habib Tanvir, with his eclectic Chhattisgarhi folk troupe, has broken every rule of progressive world theatre, only to push it forward. “The fight against Narendra Modi is the only fight right now,” he told Tehelka when he was being hounded. This man won’t bend.
 
MAHASWETA DEVI
Writer
“I am not an intellectual,” said Mahasweta Devi, some years back, “Sagar Sabar is an intellectual. He has made a home on the tree, he understands the seasons, the language of the leaves, the sound of the earth, the rivers, the birds. I am not an intellectual. Sagar Sabar is.” From Hajaar Chaurishir Ma, on the Calcutta Naxalite who becomes a mere prison number, tortured and eliminated, to Birsa Munda, the adivasi rebel, and the literary documentation of the entire tribal history of what is now Jharkhand, to her current obsession with the rights of denotified ‘criminal’ tribes, this woman is what she is: Hajaar Chaurishir Ma.
 
KANCHA ILAIAH
Academician

He is so obscure that you will miss him. But when he speaks, it’s like poison, the poison inherited by the oppressed and the dalits through five thousand years. And his poison has argument, like his seminal book, Why I am not a Hindu. There is a strange dilemma he often faces. Dogmatic dalits sometimes are cynical. Does he really represent them? “I am a Shudra,” he will say, “but that’s the same thing, isn’t it?”
 
VIJAY TENDULKAR
Playwright
Undisputed usherer of modernity in Marathi theatre. Author of more than 50 plays, each provocative and unforgiving in its indictment of issues like Brahminism and middle-class venality. Always intellectually agile and relevant, with plays like Sakharam Binder and Ghasiram Kotwal, he braved the lumpen ire of the Shiv Sena in the 1970s. Did not back off even when police vans had to patrol his lane in Mumbai. His voice can be counted on to argue against communalism and political apathy. His remarks on Modi after Gujarat — I wish I could wield a gun instead of a pen — created a furore. Declared the enfant terrible of Indian theatre five decades ago, at 77, he is still able — and willing — to swim against the stream.
 
UR ANANTHAMURTHY
Writer
Kannada litterateur UR Ananthamurthy has proved that knowledge stirs people into action. Whether it is demanding a ban on mining to save the Western Ghats or speaking up against untouchability, the writer puts his heart into any cause he takes up. He has not minced words in letting everyone know what he thinks about the likes of Narendra Modi and Pravin Togadia.
He celebrates the diversity of the land. In an interview, he said: “For them (the Europeans), a nation is one language, one race, and one relationship. If we pursue this notion, India will break. So, the only way to stay together is to decentralise.”
 
RATAN THIYAM
Theatre Personality
Ratan Thiyam is embarrassed no end when described as an intellectual. “For me, a person who has a great mind, loves his people and country, is a pillar of wisdom, thinks with imagination, intelligence and logic, and looks to create a better world to live in, is an intellectual,” he says. Thiyam feels a public intellectual has a clear moral centre, a clear conscience and strong moral values. Writer, director, designer, musician, painter and actor, Thiyam is one of the most important and influential theatre personalities, renowned for his spectacular aesthetic and potent thematic explorations. Except for a two-year stint as director of nsd in the early 80s, Manipur has remained both the physical and aesthetic foundation for his work. His plays incorporate ancient Indian theatre traditions in a modern context and express a deep concern with the search for spiritual and social equilibrium amid violence and war. His latest play, Nine hills and a Valley is, incidentally, based on the recent upheavals in his state.He describes himself as a constant observer of events around him. “I am a humanist, always looking to remove misunderstandings between people, communities and regions.” Thiyam considers Noam Chomsky as someone he can describe as a public intellectual.
 
RAM JETHMALANI
Lawyer
Over six decades, he has loomed large as one of the finest legal brains in the country and spoken out fearlessly and prolifically in the public domain, helping shape opinion on crucial issues like Emergency, Bofors, the Indira Gandhi assassination case, Mandal, the Tehelka witch-hunt, the SAR Geelani case, Gujarat riots, communalism, accountability of judges, and innumerable other issues. Brings formidable eloquence, intelligence, knowledge and legal acumen to every issue he takes up. Not a textbook case for holding consistent positions, he could be disqualified many times for what might look like political opportunism. But a curious, individualistic morality governs his actions and even at 82, he refuses to be dismissed — exuding an edgy, ready energy and willingness to engage that few others can match.
 
PRASHANT BHUSHAN
Lawyer
Inherited refined qualities, like his father — and both have fought public interest cases without money — If there is a conscience in the Indian judiciary, he represents it, among the few who still believe in judicial justice. Acidic when arguing against Supreme Court judgements which go so terribly wrong, or on contempt, he has the guts to do to what he thinks is right. The nation needs many more intellectual lawyers like him, who can stake their best against a no-win situation. But the fact is he wins, as in the Neera Yadav case.
 
AG NOORANI
Lawyer
Don’t argue with him, he knows all the arguments. And don’t dabble with him on constitutional history, he knows It all. A constitutional expert, he can give you a run for your money for details which even the finest historian might miss. And he is absolutely impeccable, he won’t write for you, barring for The Statesman for which he wrote for decades, and lately for Hindustan Times. A rare gem, among the judiciary, an intellectual who fights nonstop.
 
SUNITA NARAIN
Environment Activist
Feisty director of Delhi-based Centre for Science and Environment (CSE). Never the one to shirk battle, whether taking on Coke or fellow environmentalists. Is central to the examination of any environmental issue. Started working with Anil Aggarwal in 1980, imbibing the rigour that marks cse’s work. The first battle won was over air-pollution in Delhi, when auto manufacturers were left with no answers in the face of the data compiled. Came into her own when cse took on cola majors over pesticide levels. As head of the Tiger Task Force, she managed to tread the middle path between tribal activists and the tigerwallahs.
 
ASHIS NANDY
Social Scientist
He was rethinking Freud and clinical psychology, the small is beautiful and deschooling society thesis, and he turned the mediocre Marxist supremacy upside down by changing the methodology of conformist sociology with his Intimate Enemy. But the manner he reinterpreted popular culture broke new grounds. Besides, he took on Hindutva using their own mindless arguments and recently released a document on hunger and starvation deaths in Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh. Times are changing, and every social scientist must count. And Nandy will not turn back.
 
PRABHASH JOSHI
Journalist
Sabki Khabar Le, Sabko Khabar De. Since he launched the successful Indian Express Hindi daily, Jansatta, he has fought through many wars: Emergency, bjp, and now the upa. But his scholarship is so astounding that his public activism overshadows it. You name a public interest issue where this man is not present, even when there is a cricket match going on, because that’s truly his first passion.
 
MADHU KISHWAR
Feminist-Activist
Thought provoking, strident, an invigorating speaker and scholar, she has consistently fomented debate and pushed boundaries for 30 years. As founder editor of Manushi, a pathbreaking journal on women and society in 1979, she distinguished herself as one of India’s foremost thinkers on women’s rights and social justice. Has campaigned for diverse issues like dowry, sati, female foeticide, representation of women in politics and, most recently, the rights of rickshaw pullers. A decade ago, declared she was not a feminist. Recently has moved away from earlier liberal, radical positions to more complicated traditionalist ones. Is now vigorously anti-West; is in favour of joint families; advocates less glamourous and more respected careers for women; is disillusioned with legal redressal. Her evolving positions perplex and disturb, but they are passionately argued and cannot be ignored.
 
MT VASUDEVAN NAIR
Litterateur
When MT puts pen to paper, Kerala sits up and takes notice. Transcending modern, post-modern trends, the Jnanpith winner and feted filmmaker of Nirmalyam has always been on the side of the human being. In Kerala, that sees a Left party line as almost natural, he has walked alone. MT represents the Malabar culture, where the dominant Muslims have coexisted with the Hindus. When communalism destroyed Marad recently, he spoke out. Kerala listened. MT, 72, is not a marcher. But when the weave of life is at stake, he bestirs himself. That’s why he is invaluable.
 
RAJENDRA YADAV
Litterateur
Dalits and women are his current obsessions of historical change. He says we have been turned intellectually incompetent by our slavish inheritance of Western philosophy. Most Indo-Anglian writers have neither language nor reality, they should go and settle down in the US, he thinks. When the Rahejas were raided (Outlook), he was there, as he was when Arundhati was jailed, and he says, “I am a supporter of Tehelka.”
 
RAJNI KOTHARI
Political Scientist
Marxists in jnu hated him when he wrote that breakthrough book on caste in India. He didn’t mind. He went on with his engagement with the grassroots which anticipated the Mandal upsurge. In his final academic years, he wrote a three-volume study on the shift in Indian politics because of non-Marxist people’s movements, like the nba. Always with every human, public and intellectual cause, he was heading the SAR Geelani Defence Committee when the academic was facing the gallows on the December 13 Parliament attack.
 
K. BALAGOPAL
Activist Lawyer
Thousands of encounter murders could become legitimate in Andhra Pradesh, but for him and his human rights comrades. The State tried to kill him many times, but he refused to succumb. He helped hundreds who could have been killed in fake encounters. A Marxist who broke away from pw dogmatism, if he writes an article in EPW or on post-modernism in the Telugu papers, it can still creates huge ripples unseen in mainstream India.

Nov 05 , 2005
 
Related Stories


The Necessity of Flowered Man
The definition of the Public Intellectual escapes the best of us but can humanity escape the importance of the Public Intellectual, asks Amit Sengupta
‘In India we are at the moment witnessing a sort of fusion between corporate capitalism and feudalism — it’s a deadly cocktail’
Arundhati Roy
in conversation with Amit Sengupta
SO FAR, SO FEW
Getting to know the Intellectual
By Shoma Chaudhury
Those who make the grade
And those who don’t

Print this story Feedback Add to favorites Email this story

 
  About Us | Who’s Who@Tehelka | Advertise With Us | Print Subscriptions | Syndication | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Contact Us | Bouquets & Brickbats